Inside Vs. Outside IR35: What It Means For Your Business
In our recent blog, we explained what IR35 is. Today, we’ll explore the critical distinction between “inside” and “outside” IR35 and what it means for your business. Understanding these classifications is essential for contractors, freelancers, and businesses, as they can directly impact tax liabilities, take-home pay, and overall compliance. As experts at Carter Collins & Myer, we know how important it is to understand this difference, so we have compiled this guide just for you.
Do you want to speak to our professionals directly? Contact us today on 01706 225 617 or email enquiries@uk-ccm.com to schedule your free consultation. We specialise in guiding you through these complexities, ensuring that your business remains compliant while maximising financial efficiency. Our expert team is here to simplify the process and tailor solutions to your unique needs.
At Carter Collins & Myer, we’re committed to providing expert financial guidance with a personal touch, helping you navigate the complexities of accounting and tax with confidence and clarity.
Inside Vs. Outside IR35 – The Difference
Before diving into the details, let’s first recall what IR35 is.
HMRC introduced the IR35 rules to prevent disguised employment, in which contractors avoid paying employee-like taxes by operating through a limited company while performing the same job as a permanent employee.
What Is Inside IR35?
When you’re inside IR35, the taxman considers you to be working as an employee. You must pay Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) at the same rates as any employee. Additionally, employer NICs could also be due, reducing your take-home pay.
IR35 compliance becomes particularly important for businesses when contracts fall within IR35. Businesses must ensure that they deduct the appropriate taxes from the contractor’s pay, which can involve paying employer NICs. This can significantly impact the bottom line for businesses working with contractors.
Contractors operating inside IR35 lose the key tax advantages of being self-employed. Instead of taking advantage of paying themselves via dividends, which is tax-efficient, they are forced to pay themselves through salary, which brings higher tax rates and reduces their earnings.
What Is Outside IR35?
On the other hand, if you’re outside IR35, you are genuinely self-employed. You can enjoy the tax benefits of being a contractor, such as paying yourself through dividends, which are taxed at a lower rate than salary income.
For IR35 contractor rules, determining whether you fall outside IR35 is crucial because if you are genuinely self-employed, you can claim tax efficiencies, manage your income more flexibly, and take advantage of a broader range of allowable business expenses. Freelancers and contractors are much better off financially when they fall outside IR35, as they have more freedom to manage their earnings.
How Do You Know If You’re Inside Or Outside IR35?
Understanding IR35 for limited companies and determining whether a contract falls inside or outside of IR35 can be confusing. This is why it’s essential to assess the status of your contracts regularly. One way to check your status is through the How to Check IR35 status tool provided by HMRC, the CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax) tool.
However, while this tool can be a helpful starting point, it’s important to note that it’s not always accurate. To ensure your contracts are tax compliant and you’re not at risk of misclassification, consult an accountant who understands freelance regulations and IR35 compliance for businesses.
The three main factors that determine whether you’re inside vs. outside IR35 are:
- Control: How much control does the client have over how, when, and where you do your work? If the client has significant control, you’re likely inside IR35.
- Substitution: Can you send someone else to do the work on your behalf? If you can’t provide a substitute, it suggests you’re inside IR35.
- Mutuality of Obligation (MoO): Does your client have an ongoing obligation to offer work, and are you obliged to accept it? If this mutual obligation exists, it points to inside IR35.
| Factor | Inside IR35 | Outside IR35 |
| Tax Status | Considered an employee for tax purposes. | Considered genuinely self-employed. |
| Tax Implications | Pay Income Tax NICs (including employer NICs). | Pay tax through dividends, with fewer taxes. |
| Control | The client has significant control over your work. | You have control over how, when, and where to work. |
| Substitution | You cannot send someone else to do the work. | You can send a substitute to perform the work. |
| Mutuality of Obligation (MoO) | The client is obligated to provide work; you must accept. | There is no obligation to accept ongoing work from the client. |
| Take-home Pay | Reduced due to taxes (salary-based). | Higher take-home pay due to tax efficiencies. |
| Employer Responsibilities | The business must deduct tax and NICs. | The contractor is responsible for their taxes. |
| Contractor’s Independence | Limited independence. | Fully independent as a self-employed individual. |
The Tax Implications Of IR35
The IR35 tax implications are substantial for contractors. When you’re inside IR35, you lose out on taking advantage of dividend payments, which are taxed at a lower rate. Instead, you’ll pay yourself through a salary subject to higher taxes.
IR35 compliance becomes a priority for businesses hiring contractors. If a contractor is determined to be inside IR35, the business is responsible for deducting the correct tax and NICs from the contractor’s payment. Additionally, employer NICs may apply, adding a financial burden to the business.
The stakes are high regarding IR35 contractor rules because businesses and contractors must ensure compliance to avoid penalties from HMRC. Not complying with the legal risks of IR35 misclassification can lead to serious consequences, including backdated taxes, fines, and interest on unpaid tax.
What Are The Legal Risks Of IR35 Misclassification?
Misclassifying a contract can have significant legal risks. If a business misjudges whether a contractor is inside or outside IR35, it can face penalties for incorrect tax treatment. For example, if a contractor works inside IR35 but is treated as outside IR35, the contractor and the business may be liable for unpaid taxes.
Businesses must correctly classify their contractors to avoid the legal risks of IR35 misclassification. This includes regularly reviewing contracts, assessing working practices, and staying updated with freelance regulations to ensure compliance.
The misclassification risks for IR35 for small businesses are even more pronounced, as smaller businesses may not have the resources to handle hefty tax penalties. Therefore, small businesses must consult a tax expert to ensure they’re not at risk.
GET FREE CONSULTATION
How Does IR35 Affect Small Businesses?
IR35 can be incredibly challenging for small businesses, which typically have fewer resources to deal with complex tax issues like IR35. Contractors working with small businesses may still be required to undergo IR35 assessments, but the responsibility for compliance often lies with the business rather than the contractor.
For small businesses, it’s crucial to understand the difference between inside vs. outside IR35, as this classification can affect the overall business tax planning strategy. Consulting with experts who understand tax compliance services is key to staying compliant without paying unnecessary penalties.
Conclusion
Whether you are a freelancer, contractor, or business owner, understanding inside vs. outside IR35 is essential to managing your tax obligations and optimising your take-home pay. The rules around IR35 contractor rules can be complex, but with the proper guidance, you can navigate them successfully and avoid the significant IR35 tax implications.
At Carter Collins & Myer, we specialise in helping contractors, freelancers, and businesses navigate the complexities of IR35 compliance for businesses. Whether you need to assess the status of your contract, understand the legal risks of IR35 misclassification, or optimise your business tax planning, our expert accountants are here to provide tailored solutions to ensure you remain tax compliant and maximise your financial potential.
We also provide virtual finance director services, company secretarial services, and support across our various sectors and areas.
Contact us today on 01706 225 617 or email enquiries@uk-ccm.com to schedule your free consultation. Let’s make IR35 work for you!
